|
Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
|
Deconstructing `problem' researchers and `problem' families: A rejoinder to Garrett
Judy Nixon
Sheffield Hallam University, j.nixon{at}shu.ac.uk
In a recent article in this journal Paul Michael Garrett presents an ill-informed, selective and distorted view of our work on Intensive Family Support Projects (IFSPs) which provide specialist and intensive support to families at risk of eviction. In constructing a critique of IFSPs Garrett draws extensively on interim study findings mistakenly concluding that we are `docile' researchers lacking in critical reflexivity. In this response, we first challenge the way in which he crudely constructs IFSPs as state disciplinary mechanisms reflecting a lack of a nuanced understanding of the multiplicity of ways in which the `conduct of conduct' is performed. Secondly, we explore his use of a `disciplining gaze' to undermine the validity of both the study findings and our role as independent researchers. Finally, reflecting some of the contradictions inherent in the formation of women as gendered welfare subjects we strongly refute the allegation that our approach was gender blind and outline the various ways in which lone parent women resisted being constructed as the `anti-social other'.
Key Words: anti-social behaviour • contract research • gender • Intensive Family Support Projects • liberal governance
References
- Allan, C. (2005) `On the Social Relations of Contract Research Production: Power, Positionality and Epistemology in Housing and Urban Research', Housing Studies 20(6): 986—1007.
- Carr, H. (2007) `Women's Work: Locating Gender in the Discourse of Anti-social Behaviour', pp. 121—34 in A. Bottomley and H. Lim (eds) Feminist Perspectives on Land Law. London: Cavendish.
- Carr, H. and Cowan, D. (2006) `Labelling: Constructing Definitions of Anti-social Behaviour', pp. 57—78 in J. Flint (ed.) Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice. Bristol: Policy Press.
- Crawford, A. (2003) `Contractual Governance of Deviant Behaviour', Journal of Law and Society 30(4): 479—505.[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Dillane, J., Hill, M., Bannister, J. and Scott, S. (2001) Evaluation of the Dundee Families Project. Glasgow: Dundee City Council, Scottish Executive, NCH Scotland.
- Flint, J. (2003) `Housing and Ethopolitics: Constructing Identities of Active Consumption and Responsible Communities', Economy and Society 32(3): 611—29.[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Flint, J. (2006) Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice Bristol: Policy Press.
- Flint, J. and Nixon, J. (2006) `Anti-social Behaviour Orders', Urban Studies 43(5/6): 939—55.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Garrett, P.M. (2007) ` ``Sinbin'' Solutions: The ``Pioneer'' Projects for ``Problem Families'' and the Forgetfulness of Social Policy Research', Critical Social Policy 27(2): 203—30.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
- Hughes, G. (2002) `Crime and Disorder Partnerships: The Future of Community Safety?', pp. 123—41 in G. Hughes, E. McLaughlin and J. Muncie (eds) Crime Prevention and Community Safety: New Directions. London: SAGE.
- Hughes, G. (2007) The Politics of Crime and Community. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
- Hunter, C. (2003) `Looking Two Ways at Once: Anti-social Behaviour, Law and Social Inclusion', paper to Autumn Conference of the Housing Studies Association, Bristol, September.
- Hunter, C. (2006) `From Landlords to Agents of Social Control', pp. 137—54 in J. Flint (ed.) Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice. Bristol: Policy Press.
- Hunter, C. and Nixon, J. (2001) `Taking the Blame and Losing the Home: Women and Anti-social Behaviour', Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law 23(4): 395—410.[CrossRef]
- Hunter, C., Nixon, J. and Slatter, M. (2005) `Neighbours Behaving Badly: Anti-social Behaviour, Property Rights and Exclusion in England and Australia', Macquarie Law Journal 5: 147—76.
- Jones, A., Pleace, N., Quilgars, D. and Sanderson, D. (2006) Shelter Inclusion Project: Evaluation of a New Model to Address Anti-social Behaviour. York: Centre for Housing Policy, University of York.
- Kemeny, J. (2006) `The Faustian Bargain and the Political Sponsorship of Contract Research', ESRC (Economic and Social Research Council) seminar on the social relations of contract research production, Kings College London.
- Nixon, J. (2006) `ASBOs: More Questions than Answers', Criminal Justice Matters No. 62 (Winter): 24—6. Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
- Nixon, J. and Parr, S. (2006) `Anti-social Behaviour: Voices from the Front Line', pp. 79—99 in J. Flint (ed.) Housing and Anti-social Behaviour: Perspectives, Policy and Practice. Bristol: Policy Press.
- Nixon, J., Hunter, C., Parr, S., Whittle, S., Myers, S. and Sanderson, D. (2006a) Interim Evaluation of Rehabilitation Projects for Families at Risk of Losing their Home as a Result of ASB. London: ODPM (Office of the Deputy Prime Minister).
- Nixon, J., Hunter, C., Parr, S., Whittle, S., Myers, S. and Sanderson, D. (2006b) ASB Intensive Family Support Projects: An Evaluation of 6 Pioneering Projects. London: DCLG (Department for Communities and Local Government).
- Nixon, J., Hunter, C. and Spinney, A. (2006c) `The Gendered Nature of Policy Discourse: Patriarchy, Pathology or is there a Third Way?', paper to ENHR (European Network of Housing Research) Conference, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
- Parr, S. (2006) `Intensive Family Support: A ``New'' Front in the Fight against ASB?', paper to ENHR (European Network of Housing Research) Conference, Ljubljana, Slovenia.
- Pinson, G. (2006) `Contract Research between Skhole and Professionalism: Remarks on a Cross Work Experience in France and Britain', ESRC (Economic and Social Research Council) seminar on the social relations of contract research production, Kings College London.
- Respect Task Force (2006) Respect Action Plan. London: Home Office.
- Rose, N. (2001) `Community, Citizenship and the Third Way', in D. Merydyth and J. Minson (eds) Citizenship and Cultural Policy. London: SAGE.
- Starkey, P. (2000) `The Feckless Mother: Women, Poverty and Social Workers in Wartime and Post-war England', Women's History Review 9(3): 539—59.[CrossRef][Web of Science]
- Stephen, D. and Squires, P. (2004) `They are Still Children and Entitled to be Children: Problematising the Institutionalised Mistrust of the Marginalised Youth in Britain', Journal of Youth Studies 7(3): 351—69.[CrossRef]
- Stephen, D. and Squires, P. (2005) Rougher Justice: Anti-social Behaviour and Young People. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.
- The Observer (1999) `Academics Dub Blunkett a Tyrant in Row over Research', 21 November: 9.
- Times Higher Educational Supplement (2006) `Beating the Bullies', 1 December.
Critical Social Policy, Vol. 27, No. 4,
546-556 (2007)
DOI: 10.1177/0261018307081813
 CiteULike  Complore  Connotea  Del.icio.us  Digg  Reddit  Technorati  Twitter What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
|
|
 
P. M. Garrett
`Sinbin' research and the `lives of others': A rejoinder in an emerging and necessary debate
Critical Social Policy,
November 1, 2007;
27(4):
560 - 564.
[PDF]
|
|
|
|
|
